• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Cyberlaw clinic logo

Cyberlaw Clinic

Pro bono legal services to clients at the intersection of technology and social justice

  • TEAM
  • PRACTICE
  • RESOURCES
  • CONTACT
  • BLOG
  • Show Search
Hide Search

3dprintingindustry.com Addresses Pre-Issuance Submission Project

· June 10, 2013 ·

3DPRINTINGINDUSTRY.COM | Insider Insight — Fighting the 3D Printing Patent Applications | June 3, 2013 | 3dprintingindustry.com featured an article by the Cyberlaw Clinic’s own Kit Walsh about work that the Clinic’s done with the Electronic Frontier Foundation to file pre-issuance submissions with the United States Patent and Trademark Office.  The ongoing project has identified examples of prior art relevant to patent applications that concern 3D printing technology.  Kit’s article responded to a previous piece by attorneys John F. Hornick and Anita Bhushan of the Finnegan IP law firm in Washington, DC, in which Mr. Hornick and Ms. Bhushan criticized the Clinic’s and EFF’s work and noted the possibility that it might lead to fewer, stronger, and narrower patents in the 3D printing space.  “If giving examiners relevant prior art would reduce the ‘number and breadth’ of patents,” wrote Kit, “that means they are currently issuing overly broad, invalid patents because they do not know about critical information that’s been published . . . .  One can debate whether existing patent laws stifle and punish innovation more than they help, but it should be uncontroversial that it is a bad thing for the patent office to grant an overly-broad patent due to ignorance of critical prior art.”

Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcome. Content is for informational purposes and is not legal advice. Use of the site is not an invitation to enter into and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Do not convey information you regard as confidential unless a formal attorney-client relationship is established. Information received prior to establishment of such relationship will not be confidential.

Accessibility | Digital Accessibility

Cyberlaw Clinic

Copyright © 2025 · Monochrome Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in